Philoptima

Increasing Your Grantmaking Impact
Martin Lehfeldt
Posted on Tuesday, January 5, 2010

When markets shrink and foundation assets—despite being collectively measured in the billions of dollars—wither, we are again reminded of philanthropy’s rather relative insignificance in the great scheme of things………………..Don’t get me wrong; I don’t want to imagine a world without grant-making foundations. The evidence of the problems they have helped to solve and the emergency relief they have provided during critical times is all about us………………..And yet, despite all of their good work, we also must concede that they haven’t put much of a dent in the massive problems facing our society. All of which brings me back to the subject of advocacy and the need to support it………………..Perhaps your foundation is trying to correct the cavalierly destructive way in which we have despoiled our environment for hundreds of years. Maybe your work is focused upon the symptoms of poverty that manifest themselves in hunger and homelessness—or the struggles of rural communities to make themselves sustainable, or the need for more early childhood education in your community. Perhaps you want to sustain the arts or bring an end to the abuse of animals. More often than not, though, as you wrestle with the decisions about how to be of greatest assistance, you will discover that one of your biggest obstacles lies in the realm of public policy………………..It’s difficult enough to be discerning about your philanthropy without the additional complication of combating laws and regulations that gets in the way of good education for all children, good health care for everyone, and the protection of the air we breathe, the water we drink, and the natural eco-systems upon which we all depend. Bad public policy, in effect, is making it difficult for your grant dollars to make a difference………………..From my perspective, you have an option. If you indeed are determined to make a significant impact with your giving, by all means acknowledge the fact that your resources are limited. But instead of getting depressed, think about how you can leverage those assets by supporting organizations that are advocating for the kinds of changes in public policy that will make your other grants more effective.
No of Comments: 1
  • OK, dear readers, pay attention! This is important. Martin is sharing a lifetime of learning in just this one column. It took me years of work in the field of philanthropy to realize how very little lasting impact our donations made to large-scale systemic community problems. After banging my head against the wall of frustration, I concluded that much more could be accomplished by being patient, finding other nonprofit partners, and advocating for changes to public policy rather than spending all of our money relieving symptoms.....There isn't anything wrong with relieving symptoms, however, the real trick is the way grantmakers think about their place in the chain of solutions. Charitable giving to relieve suffering is laudable and of tremendous help but it doesn't usually improve conditions for future generations.....If you want to really change things for the better, advocacy will most certainly become one of your tools.......Unlike me, let's hope the revelation comes sooner rather than later.
  • Dr. Byron Harrell
  • Posted on Tuesday, January 5, 2010

    Post Comment





    Philoptima